12 March 2018

Potholes - a national scourge?

Potholes - a national scourge?

Large potholeLast Thursday (8th March) saw #NationalPotholeDay2018, unfortunately, coincide with International Women’s Day #pressforprogress. The latter clearly got international recognition and coverage but there was also some good media coverage for the former thanks to the hard work by Mr Pothole himself, Mark Morrell.

A long-term investment plan is needed.

Mark is quite rightly arguing that the UK roads need a proper long-term investment plan with levels of funding to match. This funding has to come from Central Government. With the squeeze on local authority budgets over recent years, repairs that have taken place have tended to be temporary rather than permanent. Ultimately, this is a false economy as the same holes will open up again months and, in some cases, weeks later. In truth, there has been a steady deterioration over a long period of time but the recent bad weather (Beast from the East) has just made things worse.

The cost is not just in property damage; human lives are at risk.

The impact of having large holes on our roads is that all road users are at risk. Car drivers can damage tyres and wheels and the impact can also affect tracking which can lead to additional wear on tyres. Most people don't bother claiming compensation from the Local Authority because it can be a long drawn out process and the initial position from their Claims Handlers tends to be that the Council cannot be held liable for the damage based on the information provided by the claimant.

More worrying and serious though is the potential significant injury to those on two wheels (motorcyclists and cyclists) who can be thrown off and injured due to a hazardous road surface. Often the defect is not clearly visible until it is too late. Between 2007 and 2016, 22 people cycling have died and 368 have been seriously injured due to the poor state and maintenance of Britain’s roads.

We are currently progressing claims for injury on behalf of many clients who have been victims of road surface defects. To succeed with these claims, evidence is required of the specific nature of the road defect and any investigations must identify fault on the part of the roads authority, contractor or some other responsible organisation.

 Success in claims involving hazardous road surfaces very much depends on various factors including the size of the pothole, its location, the nature of the defect and how long it has been in existence.

How do we prove fault?

In simple terms, we must prove two points;

  1. The local authority knew or ought to have known about the defect in advance of the accident.
  2. 
That the defect was of a severity that warranted repair prior to the incident.



If you have sustained injury or damage as a result of a hazardous road surface, you should:

  • Inform the police as soon as possible and certainly within 14 days. 
  • If you have been injured, ask the police to attend the accident scene.
  • Inform the local council of the problem and keep a note of that record, including the name of the person you spoke to and/or reference number provided
  • Obtain details of any witnesses at the scene and ask them to confirm the presence and extent of the road surface defect.
  • Take photographs and measurements - if you're unable to do this, ask someone to take photographs for you.
  • Note down as much information as you can about the location and scene of the incident.

What can the public do to help?

So, if you come across a pothole which has the potential to unseat a cyclist or a motorcyclist, take a quick photo of it and upload it to one of the three websites mentioned below. (There are also mobile apps for these sites.)

That way, the Local Authority has been notified of the defect and, depending on its severity, has an obligation to do something about it within a given timescale.

A long-term investment plan is required but it needs to start now. Things are going to get worse before they get better but we really should be sorting out our existing roads before building new ones.

Unfortunately, however, even with investment, it is inevitable that the number of injuries over the next few years is only going to increase and we will be left to pick up the pieces working to try and get our clients and their bikes back on the road.


NCRs_sm

8 April 2024

Rules of the road don't apply here

The rules of the road don’t apply on off-road routes. Lord Sandison ruling on the case of Nigel Dick v Joseph Merrick 2024

Read More >

Sir_Harry_Lauder_Road_junction_sm

21 January 2024

How long is too long?

The delay in implementing changes and improvements to dangerous junctions can have severe consequences.

Read More >

Edinburgh_Trams_sm

4 January 2024

Tram troubles and Cycling Safety

Despite the significant number of cyclists who have been injured as a result of the tram tracks, very little has been done in terms of making improvements.

Read More >

Manas_at_UCI_World_Champs_sm

19 September 2023

Volunteering at UCI World Champs

CLS Paralegal Manas Disoriya recently volunteered as a marshal for the Individual Time Trials at the UCI World Cycling Championships in Stirling.

Read More >

Vie_Velo_Tandem_sm

7 August 2023

Pedalling Together

Jo Clancy shares her thoughts about what it means to be able to cycle on a tandem with blind or visually impaired cyclists as a member of the Vie Velo tandem club in Edinburgh.

Read More >

JC3_sm

7 March 2023

Average cyclist but training like a pro

CLS Lawyer, Jo Clancy, heads to the Canaries for some Winter cycling and some serious climbing.

Read More >

Tram_Track_and_wheel_sm

5 January 2023

Cycling incidents caused by the Edinburgh tram tracks

Four separate cycling injury cases involving tram tracks in 4 key locations have recently been settled out of court but CoEC continues to deny liability.

Read More >

MIB_200_200

9 October 2022

Civil Claims and the MIB

Civil Claims for cyclists injured by an uninsured or untraced driver

Read More >

Tram_Tracks_sm

26 September 2022

Edinburgh Tram Track Injuries – will they ever stop?

£1.2m paid out in compensation claims will continue to rise unless CEC takes action now. 

Read More >

THUMBNAIL_blog_pietro_paper

19 July 2022

Cycling levels during COVID lockdowns

New paper highlights positive impact of cycling during lockdown.

Read More >

Jo_Clancy_On_Bike_2_200_150

20 December 2021

Cycling in Tenerife

Jo Clancy, CLS specialist cycling Lawyer, experiences some key differences when cycling in Tenerife compared to Scotland

Read More >

Tram_Tracks_Princes_Street_sm

9 November 2021

Tram cases update

Having recently settled three separate tram case civil claims, this blog serves as an update on the current status and position being taking by the City of Edinburgh Council with regard to settling tram cases in Edinburgh.

Read More >

Brenda_on_Road_Bike_in_Peebles_sm

5 July 2021

More sleepless nights for cyclists

Whilst overall road casualty figures are down, more cyclists have been killed or seriously injured than last year.

Read More >

CLS_Webinar_Series_2021

17 May 2021

Webinar Series 2021

In March 2021, Cycle Law Scotland took the opportunity to utilise online spaces which have grown throughout lockdown to educate people about the work we do. This blog is a summary of the key points covered within the webinar series. 

Read More >

Spaces_for_People_Waverley_Market_Princes_Street

16 May 2021

Spaces for People - cycling for life or just for Covid?

Spaces for People – Cycling for life or just for Covid? Opinion piece reviewing the Spaces for People Campaign

Read More >

Lucy_Grant_lifting_weights_sm

27 January 2021

Training during lockdown

The challenges for sprint cyclist, Lucy Grant, during lockdown without the tools for the trade

Read More >